Thoughts on construction law from Christopher G. Hill, Virginia construction lawyer, LEED AP, mediator, and member of the Virginia Legal Elite in Construction Law

Arbitration is Waivable (Even If You Don’t Mean To)

do not sit on arbitration rightsBe careful with how you act with arbitration clauses in your contracts. If you are not careful in how you act to enforce these clauses, you could find yourself stuck in court whether you like it or not.

As I stated in a recent update to a post last month, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals recently weighed in on the issue of a contractor’s waiver of its rights to arbitration under a contract. Briefly, the facts of Forrester v. Penn Lyon Homes, et. al., No. 07-2171 are as follows. The Forrester’s sued Penn Lyon and its warranty company alleging among other things a breach of express warranty based upon a warranty contract containing a mandatory arbitration clause. Instead of immediately alleging an affirmative defense based upon the arbitration clause, the defendants removed the case to federal court and litigated for 18 months before raising the arbitration defense for the first time.

The 4th Circuit (correctly in my opinion) affirmed the lower court and held that the defendants defaulted their right to arbitration because of their actions in defense of the court action and the prejudice to the plaintiffs caused by those actions.

The lesson here is two fold. First, as a contractor, be sure to raise any arbitration rights early in any litigation or you may lose those rights. The courts do not look kindly on those that sit on their rights for too long.

Second, as a plaintiff (whether homeowner, contractor or subcontractor) in a case such as Forrester, you need not point out the arbitration clause to a defendant. Depending on the situation, you may want to try the litigation route even in the face of such a clause and make the other party enforce its arbitration rights or lose them through non-enforcement.

As always, good legal counsel is key in assuring that these steps are taken in a timely manner by which your rights are protected.

Your comments are welcome and encouraged. Please subscribe to keep up with the latest Construction Law Musings.

Arbitration is Waivable (Even If You Don't Mean To)
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

3 Responses to Arbitration is Waivable (Even If You Don’t Mean To)

  1. […] @ StartTags Arbitration is Waivable (Even If You Don't Mean To …Be careful with arbitration clauses in Construction Contracts. These clauses are subject to waiver. […]

  2. Tweets that mention Arbitration is Waivable (Even If You Don’t Mean To | Construction Law Musings- Richmond, VA -- says:

    […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Christopher Hill. Christopher Hill said: This post goes well with @douglasreiser's guest post today […]

  3. E-Mail Can Waive Arbitration (sometimes- A Cautionary Tale | Construction Law Musings- Richmond, VA) says:

    […] the judicious use of these clauses to help resolve disputes to waiver of rights under these clauses through inaction, arbitration clauses permeate the construction landscape. A recent case out of the Western […]

Leave a reply