Originally posted 2010-05-17 11:04:02. Republished by Blog Post Promoter
Recently, I came across another Virginia construction case that serves as both a reminder that, in Virginia, the contract is king and that because of this fact, the contract will be enforced by its terms.
In L. White and Company v Culpeper Memorial Hospital, the plaintiff contractor (L. White and Company) sued the hospital for wrongful termination from the project. The hospital responded that the contract required exhaustion of a two stage informal resolution process prior to any suit being filed. The informal resolution required both submission of any claim to the architect and mandatory mediation. L. White and Company could show that it had submitted the claim to the architect, but conceded that it never sought to mediate it’s claim. However, L. White and Company argued that the mediation provision was merely advisory.
The Culpeper County, Virginia Circuit Court disagreed with the plaintiff and dismissed the claim in it’s entirety because the contract provided for exhaustion of the informal resolution process prior to either party filing suit. In short, both sides agreed and signed the contract and therefore both parties were going to be held strictly to it’s terms.
While I have discussed the great value of mediation on several occasions here at Musings over the past year and a half (and my thoughts on mandatory mediation), the true take away from this case for contractors, subcontractors and suppliers is to carefully read the contract documents that control your rights regarding a construction project. You, as a construction professional, should read them carefully at the time of signing the contract and any time you plan to make a claim or exercise your rights under the contract. Here, the court clearly implied that the simple act of requesting mediation could have saved the contractor’s claim (particularly if the owner did not reply or blocked mediation).
Remember, your contract is the law governing the construction project. Make sure that you carefully read and analyze that law prior to beginning work. Also, the help of a Virginia construction attorney will help avoid problems down the road.
As always, I welcome your comments below. Please subscribe to keep up with this and other Construction Law Musings.
Image via stock.xchng.
Twitter Comment
“Another Reminder to Read Your Construction Contracts”- by Construction Law Musings: [link to post] #construction #contracts
– Posted using Chat Catcher
Yet another great post Counselor! I will forward this to a few ‘key’ clients. (Too bad none are in Virginia)
Twitter Comment
Another Reminder to Read Your Construction Contracts | Construction Law Musings- Richmond, VA [link to post]
– Posted using Chat Catcher
Twitter: constructionlaw
Thanks Bobby. Let me know if you or any of your clients have VA related questions.
.-= Christopher G. Hill´s last blog post ..Random Thoughts on LEED Challenges and De-certification =-.
Twitter: melissabrumback
Chris:
Was the dismissal with or without prejudice? It didn’t say from the link you provided. If with prejudice– ouch! An expensive lesson to learn.
.-= Melissa Brumback´s last blog post ..Even Subcontractors can sue other Prime Contractors Directly on State projects (Law note) =-.
Twitter: constructionlaw
Good point Melissa. I am not sure. I could not tell from the opinion either. I hope, for the plaintiff’s sake, that the dismissal was without.
.-= Christopher G. Hill´s last blog post ..How a Legal “Blawg” Helps! (Thanks Blog for Profit) =-.
Chris,
As you have pointed out, it is not enough to read the contract but you have to follow the contract. In this case, the effort and cost of the mediation would have been less than the cost to oppose the dismissal. The outcome would have been a whole lot better too. Even if the case did not settle in mediation, the issues would have been narrowed that could have lead to a resolution before trial.
.-= Ron White´s last blog post ..RESOLVING INTERNATIONAL CONSTRUCTION DISPUTES THROUGH U.S.-STYLE MEDIATION =-.
Twitter: constructionlaw
Thanks for the insight Ron. Reading and following a well drafted contract is key
.-= Christopher G. Hill´s last blog post ..Newsflash: Musings to Invade the Advocate’s Studio =-.
[...] the weight of poor or untimely performance by its fellow subcontractors, but subcontractors must be wary of contractual language that may make them do just [...]
[...] following your contract documents to the letter will go a long way toward making sure that you, as a construction professional in Virginia (or any [...]
[...] following your contract documents to the letter will go a long way toward making sure that you, as a construction professional in Virginia (or any [...]
[...] change orders. In other words, you should make your contracts say what you want them to and then follow the provisions of those contracts. Of course, as soon as I preach from the highest mountain that this is the best and only way to go, [...]
[...] than one that doesn’t. Having a written change order provision in the contract is a must. Following that provision after explaining it to the owner will make your life as a builder much less [...]
[...] Another Reminder to Read Your Construction Contracts [...]